Working through key issues as a team requires more than a majority decision, group
thinking or just going with whatever the most senior person in the conversation thinks. It demands deliberate, thoughtful debate, discussion and ideation.
The process of thinking through options isn’t just about choosing the best path; it’s about ensuring that different perspectives are heard, blind spots are identified, and the team feels confident and committed to the final decision. Here’s how to foster constructive strategic decision making that leads to clarity and alignment:
1. Start with a Clear Statement
Revisit the goal or issue, summarize it in one sentence, and display it visibly to keep everyone focused during the discussion.
2. Ask Questions About the Statement
Before you start coming up with solutions, allow anyone and everyone to ask clarifying questions about the statement. Does it mean this or that? What is causing this issue or what is the underlying issue? When does this happen and not happen? Make sure everyone has an opportunity to ask questions about the statement with the goal of making sure you understand all the underlying issues, root causes and causations that have put the group having the discussion today. Don’t allow just one or two people to ask all the questions, ensure that those who have been quiet get a chance to participate. Often they have the questions that will break open some understanding about the statement.
Continue to write up these points so everyone can see them and get further clarity on what it is that we are debating and discussing.
3. Put All Options on the Table
Brainstorm as a group- create a space where everyone feels comfortable contributing ideas, regardless of hierarchy. Write down every potential strategy, option and idea no matter how ambitious, unconventional, or even obvious it might seem. Often one idea leads to another.
4. Narrow the Conversation
Set a time to move to narrowing the conversation. Pick out the key ideas or ask people to vote on their top 3. Track these ideas and options on the whiteboard or shared screen. Ask questions like:
What evidence do we have that this might be a good idea? What data/information might we need?
How much will this cost and is it feasible based on our budgets etc.?
Does this align with who we are (Values, Vision, Mission)
What is your gut reaction about doing this? Can you tell us more about that?
What risks are there to doing this? (ask these risk questions in the middle before asking the next question)
How could we find ways around this? (the risks or downsides)
Again, make sure everyone contributes and participates. Give space for passionate but respectful debate. The goal is to foster a culture where different points of view are seen as a strength not a threat.
5. Conclude with a Decision
After all viewpoints have been considered, it’s time to decide. Strive for consensus where possible but recognize that getting everyone to agree isn’t always feasible. The leadership might need to make the decision and ask the team to support it during implementation. Ensure that the team has complete buy-in or the implementation will fail.
Making a mediocre decision is better than not making a decision at all. Following the final decision and committing to it are key, in the face of personal preferences and departmental biases. Commit to trusting each other and the power of the team.
Why Debate Matters
This process isn’t just about picking the “right” strategy—it’s about building trust, alignment, and shared commitment. When executives contribute, they’re more likely to support and execute the strategy. The best strategies aren’t always easy to choose, but they’re the ones your team believes in. While discussions and debates can feel messy, they bring clarity and focus. Embrace the challenge—it shows your team cares about getting it right. In the end, this effort strengthens your strategy and sets your business up for success.
The Role of Openness and Vulnerability
Healthy strategic debates are built on trust, which grows when leaders are open and vulnerable.
True collaboration requires honesty, admitting uncertainties, and setting aside ego for the team’s benefit. Leaders who acknowledge gaps in knowledge foster curiosity and create a safe space for innovative ideas. Sharing fears or biases openly helps address blind spots, while active listening and understanding others’ perspectives strengthen trust. This openness ensures alignment, as leaders feel heard and are more likely to commit to decisions. Vulnerability is a leadership strength that builds trust, alignment, and unified action, driving organizational success.
Now is the time to take your Team to the next level and build out a successful strategy for the future that everyone has bought into.
Set up a time to talk for 30 minutes: https://calendly.com/stephen_e_wright/lets_talk